“Exploring the Success and Struggles of Remaking Iconic Music Videos”

Comparing Original Music Videos to Their Remakes

Comparing Original Music Videos to Their Remakes


Music videos have become a crucial part of a musician’s image and brand. An iconic music video can make or break a song’s success. Some music videos have become so famous that they’ve inspired remakes or parodies. Let’s take a look at some of the most memorable original music videos and their remakes.

90s Classics

“Baby One More Time” by Britney Spears

Britney Spears’ “Baby One More Time” music video became an instant hit in 1999. The video features a high school setting, with Britney in a suggestive schoolgirl outfit. The video’s success can be attributed to its perfect blend of catchy music, dance moves, and Britney’s sex appeal.

Remake: “Baby One More Time” by Travis

Travis’ version of “Baby One More Time” was a unique take on the classic. The video featured the band members in school uniforms, playing the song on their instruments. The video’s simplicity worked in its favor, resulting in a fun and lighthearted tribute to Britney’s iconic video.

“Sabotage” by Beastie Boys

The music video for Beastie Boys’ “Sabotage” was directed by Spike Jonze, and it’s a perfect homage to 1970s cop shows. The video features the band members in wigs and fake mustaches, starring in a fictional police drama. The video’s hilarious action sequences and witty dialogue make it a timeless classic.

Remake: “Sabotage” by Jimmy Fallon, The Roots, and Chris Pine

Jimmy Fallon and The Roots’ version of “Sabotage” was already impressive, but Chris Pine’s addition took it to the next level. The video shows the trio dressed up as cops, performing the song in front of a green screen. The video’s use of onscreen graphics and effects make it a fun and entertaining tribute to the original.

2000s Bangers

“Crazy in Love” by Beyonce ft. Jay-Z

Beyonce’s “Crazy in Love” music video is a perfect example of an artist’s evolution. The video features Beyonce in a revealing outfit, dancing in front of cars and helicopters. The video’s flashy visuals and Beyonce’s sensual performance make it a classic.

Remake: “Crazy in Love” by Sofia Karlberg

Sofia Karlberg’s version of “Crazy in Love” is a stripped-down, moody take on the song. The video shows Sofia singing in black and white, with subtle camera movements and effects. The video’s minimalist approach works well with the song’s emotional vocals.

“Since U Been Gone” by Kelly Clarkson

Kelly Clarkson’s “Since U Been Gone” music video features the singer wreaking havoc on her ex-boyfriend’s possessions. The video’s energetic performance and colorful visuals make it a standout music video from the 2000s.

Remake: “Since U Been Gone” by A Day to Remember

A Day to Remember’s version of “Since U Been Gone” is a punk-rock take on the original. The video shows the band performing the song on stage, with fans participating in a mosh pit. The video’s rock and roll energy elevates the song to a new level.

Remake Fails and Wins

Fail: “Bad Blood” by Taylor Swift ft. Kendrick Lamar

Taylor Swift’s “Bad Blood” music video was a highly anticipated release in 2015. The video featured a star-studded cast, including Kendrick Lamar and Selena Gomez. However, the video’s attempts to make Taylor Swift look like an action star fell flat, resulting in a forgettable video.

Win: “I Will Survive” by Gloria Gaynor (Cake Version)

Cake’s version of “I Will Survive” is a humorous take on the disco classic. The music video features John McCrea, the band’s lead singer, driving a car while various strange occurrences happen around him. The video’s deadpan humor and creativity make it a successful remake.


Overall, original music videos and their remakes can vary in quality and success. A successful music video should stand on its own, while a remake should bring a new perspective or twist to the original. When done well, a remake can breathe new life into a classic song and make it relevant for a new generation.

What are your favorite original music videos and their remakes? Let us know in the comments below!